Should You Rely on Google Ad Recommendations & Smart Bidding? - Adpearance

Should You Rely on Google Ad Recommendations & Smart Bidding?

Weighing the pros and cons for auto dealers.

We’re all trying to do more with less, and Google has created a variety of tools aimed at helping businesses do just that. Within Google Ads, Recommendations and Smart Bidding are two features that use Google’s machine learning algorithms and claim to help advertisers run their campaigns more efficiently and effectively. But are they actually worth your time?

After more than a decade evaluating enhancements from Google and managing PPC campaigns for auto dealers, here are our takeaways.

Ad Recommendations

In your Ads account, Google provides recommendations to help improve your ad creative and campaigns. These customized suggestions may introduce you to new features, share ways to adjust your bidding strategy and get more from your budget, or help improve your optimization score.

Implementing recommendations from Google while managing campaigns on its ad platform may seem like a safe bet, but you should think critically about each recommendation before moving forward. Accepting 100% of these recommendations could actually increase costs, limit reach, and negatively impact your overall strategy.

Your dealership has clear goals and well-defined strategies that you should weigh against Google’s recommendations. Without careful consideration, a recommendation that doesn’t align with your goals or take into account your unique targeting strategy can derail performance. Additionally, many industries and brands have advertising or compliance guidelines that prohibit the use of certain language that is otherwise relevant to your business. For instance, there are often restrictions on advertising used vehicles or fixed ops in campaigns focused on new car advertising. Guidelines like these are not taken into account when Google generates suggested headlines and descriptions.

TL;DR: Don’t accept every recommendation. Take the time to consider the pros and cons of each, and only implement recommendations that will improve performance and make your ad campaigns more competitive.

Smart Bidding

Smart Bidding uses Google’s machine learning algorithms to automatically adjust bids throughout the day with the goal of maximizing your ad spend and improving your campaign results. Automated bidding may save you time and energy, but results vary when it comes to saving money

In automotive, when your advertising goal is to generate leads who either reach out to your dealership or walk into your physical store-front, your bid strategies should focus on generating leads. We work with hundreds of car dealerships across the country and are running numerous tests to see how Smart Bidding impacts campaign performance. We assume that one day smart bidding will outperform traditional bidding for certain dealers. But today, it’s not uncommon for campaigns with Smart Bidding to spend more than campaigns with manual bidding. In fact, tests we’ve run have shown that campaigns with a ‘Maximize Conversions’ bidding type experience up to 4x higher CPC and higher Cost Per Conversion due to higher costs that do not translate into a comparable increase in conversions. 

Because of cases like this, we recommend carefully reviewing your internal data and making sure automated bidding performs better before implementing across campaigns. Smart Bidding still has a ways to go before it is definitively better than manual bidding, but we are starting to see degrees of success across some accounts and testing new strategies every day.

If you need help managing your digital advertising campaigns effectively, reach out. Our team of digital advertising strategists monitors accounts and updates bids on a daily basis to ensure dealers get the most from their ad spend. We can work with you to assess ad recommendations, actively manage your accounts, and help your dealership succeed. Request a free digital analysis to learn more. 

Get monthly newsletters with timely blogs and occasional announcements for resources including in-depth reports, data-driven insights, and webinars. Once subscribed, you can select your preferences to get only what matters to you.

On-Demand Webinar
Why Connected TV is Taking Over Traditional TV Advertising
On-Demand Webinar
How to Measure Your Digital Success
About the Author

Damon Melton

Damon is a senior digital advertising specialist at Adpearance. He stays at the forefront of digital advertising technology to help drive results for auto dealerships.

Adpearance is the digital marketing company obsessed with generating quality leads. Our solutions combine cutting-edge technology, premium tracking, and an expert team to transform business results.

Follow Us

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

For security, use of Google's reCAPTCHA service is required which is subject to the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Come on... You know you want to.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get monthly newsletters with timely blogs and occasionally announcements for resources including in-depth reports, data-driven insights, and webinars.

Subscribe Form

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.